Heuristics Rules for Process Equipment
by Marthin Winner on 18/03/08 at 1:55 am | 9 Comments | |
When we were asked by our manager or supervisor to make process design or asked by our lecturer to make a preliminary plant design, we often spend so much time reading a bunch of literatures. This is the summary of article that I found in chemical engineering magazine (www.che.com). If applied with thought and care, heuristics like these can make life much easier during project scoping, preliminary plant design, process design, equipment specification and similar tasks.
Fluid handling
- Fans are suitable for raising gas pressures moderately (for instance, by 3%, or by 12 in. of water); for higher pressures up to about 40 psig, blowers are suitable; for yet higher pressures, employ compressors (however there is overlap between the operating ranges of blowers and compressors)
- Typical polytropic efficiencies for large centrifugal compressors are about 76 to 78%; rotary compressors normally have efficiencies around 70%, except for liquid-sealed ones, which have efficiencies around 50%
- For pipe lines of diameter D in inches, typical fluid velocities and pressure drops are as follows:
- for pump discharge (liquid): (5 + D/3) ft/s, and 2 psi/100 ft;
- at pump suction (liquid): (1.3 + D/6) ft/s and 0.4 psi/100 ft;
- for steam or gas, 20D ft/s and 0.5 psi/100 ft
- Control valves function best if the pressure drop through them is at least 10 psi
- Single-stage centrifugal pumps can operate at rates of up to about 5,000 gal/min, (and to maximum heads of 500 ft); multistage pumps can operate to about 11,000 gal/min.
Conveying of particulate solids
- Screw conveyors:
- Can transport solids that are abrasive or sticky
- Typical incline is about 20 deg
- Most are 150 ft or less in length
- With a conveyor of 12-in. diameter, throughputs of up to about 3,000 ft3/h are feasible; typically, screw rotation rates are up to about 60 rev/min
- Power consumption relatively low
- Bucket elevators:
- Vertical transport of abrasive or sticky materials is feasible
- Typically, speeds can reach 100 to 300 ft/min; at 100 ft/min, bucket elevators with 20X20-in. buckets can convey about 1,000 ft3/h
- Drag type conveyors:
- Can convey for relatively short distances in any direction
- Have high power requirements
- Typical speeds are 30 ft/min (for,e.g., fly ash) to 250 ft/min (for grains)
- Pneumatic conveyors:
- They offer high capacity
- Usually employed with convey-ing distances of 400 ft or less
- Can transport simultaneously to several destinations
- Operate under vacuum or low pressures
- Typical conveying-gas velocities are 35 to 120 ft/s
Cooling towers
- In full-scale units, air saturation can reach 90%
- To minimize pressure drop (ordinarily a maximum of 2 in. water), employ an open structured material for the tower fill
- Typical water circulation rates are 1 to 4 gal/min per square foot, whereas the air rates are 1,300 to 1,800 lb/h per square foot, or 300 to 400 ft/min
- Countercurrent induced-draft towers, which can cool water to about 2°F above the wet-bulb temperature, are the most prevalent version of tower used in the process industries
- For a given service, the required size (volume) of a given tower is a function of the difference between the wet-bulb and the exit temperatures; the smaller the difference, the larger the required volume
- Evaporation losses are typically 1% of the circulation for every 100°F of cooling range. Windage or drift losses in mechanical-draft towers typically amount to 0.1 to 0.3%. To keep salt from building up exces-sively, it is typical to blow down 2.5 to 3% of the circulation Heat exchangers; refrigeration
- In a shell-and-tube exchanger, the tube side is for corrosive, fouling, scaling and/or high-pressure fluids; the shell side is for viscous and/or condensing fluids
- Typical minimum temperature approaches are 20°F with normal coolants, or 10°F or less with refrigerants
- Ordinarily, the maximum heat transfer area for shell and tube heat exchangers is about 5,000 ft2
- When refrigerating to temperatures below about – 80°F, it is customary to use cascades of two or more refrigeration stages
Evaporators
- The maintaining of a suitable temperature gradient (for instance, about 45°F) can minimize film-related efficiency losses. From an efficiency standpoint, about 250 Btu/(h)(ft2) is a suitable overall coefficient of heat transfer
- In countercurrent evaporation systems, a suitable temperature approach between the inlet (hot) and output (cold) streams is about 30°F. In multistage operation, the typical minimum value is 10°F
- In a well-designed evaporator system, it should be possible to achieve heat recoveries of more than 75%


9 Comments
michaeljubel
Nov 11th, 2007
wah.. ada author baru nih.. hehe.. btw artikelnya berguna banget nih buat kita RP ntar.. daripada abis waktu ngulik-ngulik buku litaratur seabrek-abrek.. hehehe.. btw marthin kerja dimana? oiya mo nanya dong.. di dunia kerja nanti, mana yang lebih kepake? teori literatur apa heuristics??
agung prasetio
Nov 11th, 2007
wuih..mantep Bang!!! Bahasannya komprehensif banget ni, dan aplikatif sekali..Tinggal gmana temen2 kita dari jurusan mesin bisa membuat semua alat sendiri ni. Biar pabrik2 yang kita buat ntr berbasis lokal berkualitas internasional:D
Marthin
Nov 11th, 2007
Hola, Skrg gw kerja di duri,kota penghasil minyak tp jalannya bolong2..hehe..kalo cuti atau company busineess di jkt, rasanya udah spt liburan..hehe..
Btw..
Kalau udah ke tahap detail design, so pasti rule of thumb spt ini tidak bisa dipakai satu2nya sumber informasi, harus dicompare/diverifikasi dengan metoda perhitungan yg lebih presisi, metoda2 tsbt bisa didapatkan di berbagai standar internasional yg telah diakui dan dipakai banyak industri. Dan jgn kaget kalo terkadang standar perusahaan A beda dengan perusahaan B, terkdg itu yg bikin pusing designer =), dan informasi ini aku berani share ke kalian krn at least materi ini udah pernah dipublish di journal internasional (yg pastinya udah direview dulu ama dukunnya teknik kimia). Untuk pre-design atau studi2 awal, pengetahuan spt ini sangat membantu menghemat waktu (karena hasilnya jg ndak beda2 jauh jg kok).
Smg makin banyak alumni/praktisi yg mw share informasi lwt media ini..
later on kalo sempat aku akan submit artikel ttg salah satu alat yg paling banyak dipakai di pabrik..yaitu pompa..
idiothiquetotal
Nov 12th, 2007
Haar lange tijd geen zie je, en ik vond je hier. Hoe gaat het met je?
But, good job dude.
Alow Marthin, pakabar lu?? Udah lama kita gak ketemu, terakhir kapan yah? Pas TPB kalau gak salah. Dan sekarang, gw malah nemu karya-yang-sangat-high-tech sekali
michaeljubel
Nov 12th, 2007
nahh.. Skrg giliran idiothiquetotal yg bikin karya yang sangat hitech sekali.. Hehehe.. Ditunggu bgt artikel dari idiothiquetotal.. Hehe.. Bs sharing ttg apapun yg berhubungan dengan Teknik Kimia.. Dan gak harus anak TK doang kan yg nulis.. Hehe.. Ditunggu!
razzz
Nov 12th, 2007
Wehehehe… Mantap kali ni artikel Bang Marthin..hehehee…
Cuma mo kasih saran.. kalo RP sebisa mungkin jangan keseringan pake rule of thumb yaaa…
Soalnya kalo keseringan ntar ga tau konsep dasarnya.heehee..
Yang penting pelajari dulu konsepnya, tau filosofinya dasarnya dan hukum2 yang mendukung, kuasai cara kerjanya, baru abis itu cari darimana rule of thumb itu berasal.
Biar kalo tiba2 ditanya sm orang iseng di tengah jalan (ga mungkin bgt yak!) bisa jawab dengan oke..heheee…
Salam,
razzz aka ricky a.s.
02090
Webworm
Nov 16th, 2007
Great stuff…
Let me share another great one HERE…
http://www.aiche.org/uploadedFiles/Students/DepartmentUploads/heuristics.pdf
Enjoy…
Visit me at http://webwormcpt.blogspot.com/
Efrat
Nov 16th, 2007
eh heuristicnya keren juga
-arko-
Feb 5th, 2008
Mantaps, Bang Marthin…
rule of thumb-nya bisa buat acuan teman2 yang sedang puzink ngerjain plant design…
regards
-arko-
Leave a Comment